St. Charles Mom Headed to Prison for Failing to Stop Toddler’s Beating
Cathleen A. Koch refused to protect her toddler from a boyfriend who severely beat her in 2010. He already is serving a 15-year term.
ST. CHARLES, IL—A judge on Wednesday sentenced a 30-year-old mother to eight years in prison because she refused to protect her daughter from her boyfriend, who punched the 23-month-old girl 10 times and slammed her face-first into a bed in 2010.
Cathleen A. Koch, whose last known address was in the 1500 block of East Main Street, St. Charles, pleaded guilty to one count of aggravated domestic battery, a Class 2 felony; five counts of obstructing justice, each a Class 4 felony; and seven counts of child endangerment, each a Class A misdemeanor. In addition, Koch agreed that the actions that caused injury to her daughter were exceptionally brutal or heinous in nature and indicative of wanton cruelty.
Before he announced the sentence, Sixteenth Circuit Judge Timothy Q. Sheldon noted that throughout the court proceedings, which date back nearly two years, and even in her statement to the court on Wednesday, that Koch remained “'I' focused” — as in focused on herself — and showed little if any remorse for her role in her daughter’s severe injuries, and that Koch had not accepted responsibility for her role.
“It is unconscionable to this court that a loving parent wouldn’t sacrifice everything to protect a child.” — 16th Circuit Court Judge Timothy Q. Sheldon
The beating occurred Oct. 27, 2010, in a hotel room in the 1500 block of East Main Street, St. Charles.
Co-defendant James C. Cooper, 29, most recently of the 1500 block of East Main Street, St. Charles, was sentenced March 30, 2012, to 15 years in prison in exchange for a guilty plea to one count of aggravated battery to a child, a Class X felony. He is serving his sentence at Big Muddy Correctional Center in downstate Ina.
The child immediately was unresponsive, not breathing and bleeding from her mouth after the beating, which authorities said caused severe and permanent brain injuries and broken bones. Koch was in the room during the beating but refused to stop Cooper or intervene on the child’s behalf. Koch was not injured in the incident.
The Kane County State’s Attorney’s Office said Koch was charged because she is legally responsible for the abusive acts of Cooper, her boyfriend. Illinois Appellate courts have held that a person aids another person in the commission of an offense where she has an affirmative duty to act to protect her child but chooses not to act.
According to authorities, after she called 911 to report the girl’s injuries, Koch repeatedly lied to police about the cause of the child’s injuries and Cooper’s whereabouts, and provided other misleading and inaccurate information about Cooper.
During Koch’s sentencing hearing, the state presented evidence that Koch, as a result of her six-month relationship with Cooper, repeatedly allowed the child to be in harm’s way and refused to remove the child from danger despite her belief that Cooper represented a threat to both of them. The state also presented evidence that, as a result of the Oct. 27, 2010, abuse, the child, now 4, is permanently handicapped, developmentally delayed, cannot feed herself and cannot run or hop.
Koch was sentenced to eight years in prison on the domestic battery charge and one year in prison on the obstructing justice charges. The terms are to be served concurrently. Koch was sentenced to pay fines on the child endangerment charges.
According to Illinois law, Koch must serve at least 85 percent of the sentence. Koch receives credit for one day served in the Kane County Jail.
Koch, who had been free on $10,000 bond, was taken into custody when she was sentenced.
“Despite Ms. Koch’s protestations, the true victim in this case is the little girl. Ms. Koch’s attempt to divert attention away from the child and upon herself as the victim is indefensible,” Kane County State’s Attorney Joe McMahon said. “Our office has been committed to justice for this child, who was repeatedly and so needlessly exposed to violence by the person who was legally responsible to protect her. Ms. Koch effectively abandoned her daughter when the child should have been able to trust that her mother would protect her.
“Although Ms. Koch ultimately did accept legal responsibility to the court for her refusal to protect her daughter from a violent man, we have maintained that justice in this case must include a significant prison term in part because of Ms. Koch’s inexcusable transgression against her child and in part because not one among us should for a second believe that refusing to protect a young child — refusing to even attempt to protect a child — is tolerable. This sentence reflects the significance of Ms. Koch’s inaction and the gravity of the injuries to the child.
“Thanks again to St. Charles Police Chief Jim Lamkin, St. Charles Police Cmdr. Jerry Gatlin, the entire St. Charles Police Department for its thorough investigation of this case, the Kane County Child Advocacy Center, and to Kane County Assistant State’s Attorney Joseph Cullen and Debra Bree, for their hard work in prosecuting this case.”
Related:
- Man Accused in Toddler Beating Pleads Guilty
- CourtWatch: Accused Mom Will Go to Trial in March; Prison Sentence for Flasher at St. Charles Gym
- CourtWatch: Fight Continues Regarding Statements Made by Accused Mother of Beating Victim
- In Courts: Cathleen Koch, GHS Death Threat Cases on Dockets This Week
- Indicted Mother Seeks Visitation Rights to Daughter
Follow St. Charles Patch on Facebook and on Twitter at @StCharlsILPatch.
Let St. Charles Patch save you time. Get more local articles like this delivered right to your inbox or smartphone with our free newsletter. Fast signup here.
Pam
7:22 am on Thursday, September 27, 2012
Good.
thefunkychicken
7:41 am on Thursday, September 27, 2012
"Mother" is not a description of this animal.
keith golay
7:49 pm on Thursday, September 27, 2012
should be fried both of them what the hell could a child do to deserve this
David L. Arnce
8:26 pm on Thursday, September 27, 2012
I agree, and eight years is too short. Put this animal on a chaingang, and work off some of those pounds...Can we sterilize her also ?
mary barnes
12:15 am on Friday, September 28, 2012
She is not an animal because animals have a heart and they don't kill their young but protect them. There is no excuse for this fat pos and she will get hers in prison. Won't get no loving from a guy but bet she does from another fat slob like her. May she rot in hell
Patty Skowronski
2:40 pm on Thursday, September 27, 2012
she needs to be locked up for the rest of her life since she allowed her daughter's life to be destroyed.
Danielle Buske
3:41 pm on Thursday, September 27, 2012
I am sooooo disgusted I want to cry. They both need longer sentencing or have the same thing be done to them as what he did to that innocent little girl. How unfair for them to treat the child like that. Now she is handicapped. Unreal! So unfair to her so unfair. If they didn't want her give her up! There's plenty of help. There's parents who can't have kids and yet this continues to happen. I think sadly before a baby leaves a hospital they need to start background checks or something on the parents first.
Jennifer David
3:45 pm on Thursday, September 27, 2012
Eight and fifteen years. Pathetic. How about a life sentence?
Bob
3:59 pm on Thursday, September 27, 2012
Anyone that hurts a child should forfeit their life. Hope he and she get's theirs in prison, the pigs.
Marie Moody
3:59 pm on Thursday, September 27, 2012
I agree with all of the above. What is wrong with our judicial system here. Clearly it was an open and shut case. The jerk boyfriend is clearly a psychopath and should be committed and never let out in society again, and the mother because I don't see the whole story I don't care if he threatened her with a lead pipe as big as she is she probably could've took him and bashed him one I would've. Unless he had a gun she could've ran to the nearest phone even dialed 911 while screaming for help. Me I would've bashed his head in if he tried to touch my child the first time. WHAT A SICK SICK SITUATION! That poor child I hope she's with a much more loving family, Poor baby I want to cry too. OMG GOD WILL TRULY RECKON WITH THEM AND I hope they're ready for very warm climate./
Stephanie
4:00 pm on Thursday, September 27, 2012
They both should get life. This little girl lost a shot at an average life and so should they. This is a slap on the wrist.
sheryll
4:27 pm on Thursday, September 27, 2012
any child that is harmed in ANY WAY SHOULD CARRY LIFE SENTANCE. im appalled at the the small price of 8 yrs in prison for harming this child. and they plead guilty due to insanity that should speak volumes. insane needs life to protect other people from harm.
Newte Four
5:12 pm on Thursday, September 27, 2012
I just cant imagine how a mother could just stand there and watch,,my natural instinct would be to attack the man and possibly kill him to protect my child,,obviously the man is a coward to beat a baby, i know i could easily take him.....
Trisha Lynn Dragon
6:30 pm on Thursday, September 27, 2012
Yeah whatever lady. You're fulla ****. No doubt in my mind if I had come upon or seen this occurring I would be heading to prison and these crap stains masquerading as humans would be on the way to the morgue. I don't give a **** WHO the child belongs to.
I can not wrap my mind around someone witnessing something like this and NOT flying into a murderous rage. I'm generally peace loving but some things are intolerable on every level and will short circuit my better judgement. Jail or leave monsters like this to roam about or breed again? Jail. No doubt.
mother of four
6:35 pm on Thursday, September 27, 2012
I don't know why they don't do this more often. I always hear stories of a "boyfriend" beating a woman's child, and this is the first time I have ever seen the mother forced to take responsibility for letting her child be harmed. Hope it's not the last!
Hugh Hadfield
7:46 pm on Thursday, September 27, 2012
Ugly hog. She probably didn't want the child anyway since it was likely a product of drunken lust. That is the bottom line problem with these situations in my opinion. People can have babies without any paternal plan for their child's future and the scacrifices that a parent must make to nurture a young human. So when the time comes when the unfit parent decides to pursue their own self gartification again by whaterever means, the child is simply in the way and is treated a piece of unwanted garbage. Makes me want to puke.
Noelene Jones
9:46 pm on Thursday, September 27, 2012
This poor defenceless child is serving life sentence as a result of her treatment at the hands of these animals, her pathetic excuse for a mother and her boyfriend should be given life sentences also!
thomas ogden
11:39 pm on Thursday, September 27, 2012
As a parent I would kill anyone that would become such threat to the health and well being of my children. We are the only protection which our babies have, for by the time CPS gets involved, the damage has already been done. Besides any person who would so harm a child is a monster, and needs to be removed from the face of the earth.
Micheolle Neff
12:31 am on Friday, September 28, 2012
Why didnlt she get in the way of his fists, I would have I would have picked up anything I couild find that was heavey and battered him with it-- by the time I was finshed with him he would have been singing soprano
JuleS
10:40 am on Saturday, September 29, 2012
I hope this fat pig (though I guess that would be an insult to pigs) has the opportunity to read every one of these comments, and I hope further that everyone remembers her when she gets out (probably in a few years for "good behavior") and she is an outcast from society for the rest of her sorry-ass life. If anyone ever laid a hand on either of my children, he'd be 6 feet under. Cooper's15-year sentence, too, was too short -- even though the little girl didn't die, he took her life and should be in prison for the rest of his life. Anyone who beats a child to that extent will never be rehabilitated -- his behavior is ingrained, part of his DNA, and he should never be allowed to be free among us.
This bitch (and that's an insult to female dogs) obviously should have given up her child at birth; she's unfit to be a mother or for that fact, a member of civilized society. As noted in the story, she was completely focused on her own circumstances, showing no remorse whatsoever for her daughters permanent debilitation.
Why Koch got off with eight years is beyond my comprehension. Sheldon (the "judge") failed in his responsibilities to mete out the greater punishment Koch deserved; and justice failed to be served.
Ted Schnell
7:52 pm on Saturday, September 29, 2012
This was horrendous, there is no way around it. But I would take exception to name-calling. It never solved anything and really does nothing to address the issue at hand.
Ed
3:15 pm on Sunday, October 28, 2012
This is in response to the comment below. There was no "Reply" button on the comment:
"This was horrendous, there is no way around it. But I would take exception to name-calling. It never solved anything and really does nothing to address the issue at hand."
I would disagree. When someone commits an act as contemptible as this, simply saying "This was a terrible thing" does not adequately assign the blame and contempt to the person who committed the act. These were not people who made mistakes, these were people who made conscious choices to harm a child, and to apparently repeatedly put her in harm's way. Unfortunately, as a society we have become too genteel in the manner in which we treat the guilty, not allowing them (and others who may be on the brink) to understand the utter disdain with which they and their actions are viewed. Societal disapproval, in the strongest terms, is what is needed is a case such as this. I won't call her "fat" or "ugly" (at least not in a physical sense). There are those who fall into those categories, but who are wonderful people. She is not, and I cannot refer to her as anything above despicable, and the cowardly boyfriend who beat up a two-year-old sits below that.
Name-calling? That's what we should avoid? I think that perhaps we simply need to be more adroit at the names we choose.
Private User
3:26 pm on Wednesday, January 23, 2013
JuleS just comes on this board to use foul language and degrade others. She really needs to be banned. She is an embarassment to the Tri-Cities and to this community.
JuleS
11:00 am on Saturday, September 29, 2012
Here's an interesting story about the "judge" in the Koch case, who saw fit to sentence her to a short 8 years in prison for letting her boyfriend beat the life out of her daughter. In the case referenced below, he sentenced someone to 30 DAYS for a drunk driving accident that KILLED a 17-year-old. When Sheldon delivered the sentence, the father of the victim shouted out, "How much did they pay you this time?" and sheldon responded by citing the father in contempt of court and hauling HIM off to jail. A witness in the courtroom told WBBM that he has never seen anything like it — especially a tirade by a judge directed toward the parents of a teenager who died in a DUI crash.
Wake up, voters, and start making more informed decisions of whom you elect to properly interpret the law. Koch, Cooper, drunk drivers, elder abusers, thieves, rapists -- all are, or will be, living among us freely thanks to judges who, for whatever reason, can't or won't lock up these animals to protect the rest of us.
(Credit: CBS)
A Kane County judge Thursday met an outburst in his courtroom with a contempt citation — and an outburst of his own.
Someone who was in Judge Timothy Sheldon’s courtroom Thursday told WBBM Newsradio that he has never seen anything like it — especially a tirade by a judge directed toward the parents of a teenager who died in a DUI crash.
jennifer
5:24 pm on Saturday, September 29, 2012
makes a lot of sense! I was talking to a friend about this, and wow he will have to serve about 12 of the 15 years, and was shocked that HE WAS GIVEN A DEAL!!! just to plead guilty so the state didnt have to waste money on a court trial...(assuming the child is still alive) the child is going to be mentally handicapp the rest of their life, meanwhile mom and boyfriend will get out with still enough time to have a decent life, friggen discusting, all because the state is too effing lazy to put real criminals behind bars for the time they should be serving!!!
LaShelle Cobb
11:35 pm on Saturday, September 29, 2012
U gave these child abusers tht small amount of time but u will giv a person tht is selling mary jane 40 years smh really no I dont agree with selling any type of drugs but I dont get how u cn giv a person tht took away this child's chance to hav a normal life only a slap on the hand but the weed dealer u kick him under the jail smh
JuleS
8:31 am on Sunday, September 30, 2012
Hard to believe but a lot of what dictates prison terms is the sorry state of the Illinois budget. There is just not enough money to incarcerate everyone who deserves it, certainly for great lengths of time, and that's probably a lot of why degenerates like Koch and Cooper get off with relatively light sentences. That's why I'm a staunch believer in capital punishment in cases of absolute, undeniable guilt.
Matt Sullivan
4:38 am on Sunday, February 17, 2013
Ummm...Police? If you want someone to kill this b*tch...I'll do it, as long as you promise to drop the charges...but seriously, this is just sick! I'm disgusted both by her fugly face and ANYBODY who would abuse a child like that... seriously want to vomit. wtf!?